Now Reading
The HR Playbook for Handling Difficult Employees

The HR Playbook for Handling Difficult Employees

difficult employees handbook
Reading Time: 8 minutes

In today’s workplace environment, human resources (HR) professionals are often faced with the challenge of managing difficult employees. These individuals can negatively impact productivity, employee morale, and workplace harmony. This comprehensive HR playbook will provide you with the tools and strategies necessary to handle and address difficult employees effectively.

Understanding Difficult Employees

Difficult employees can be a challenge for any organisation. Their behaviour can negatively impact the workplace, causing decreased morale, increased stress, and reduced productivity. However, before effectively managing a difficult employee, it’s important to understand the factors contributing to their problematic behaviour.

One of the first steps in understanding difficult employees is identifying the types of difficult employees that exist. This involves recognizing the specific behaviours that each employee presents and addressing them accordingly.
Some common types of difficult employees include:

  • The ‘gossip’ – This individual spreads rumours and creates unnecessary drama in the workplace. This can lead to decreased morale and increased stress among other employees.
  • The ‘underminer’ – This employee actively tries to undermine others, creating a toxic work environment. This can lead to decreased productivity and increased turnover.
  • The ‘procrastinator’ – This individual consistently misses deadlines and creates bottlenecks in the workflow. This can lead to reduced efficiency and increased stress for other employees.
  • The ‘slacker’ – This employee does the bare minimum and is unwilling to take on additional responsibilities. This can lead to decreased productivity and increased workload for other employees.
  • The ‘complainer’ – This individual constantly complains about work-related issues but rarely offers any solutions. This can lead to decreased morale and increased stress among other employees.

Of course, these are just a few examples, and many other difficult employees might be present in your workplace. The important thing is to recognise the specific issues each employee presents and address them accordingly.

It’s also important to recognise the impact that difficult employees can have on your organisation. In addition to the adverse effects on morale, stress, and productivity, difficult employees can create potential legal or reputational risks for your organization. As an HR professional, it’s essential to recognise these issues and act promptly to mitigate these employees’ negative impacts on the workplace.

Assessing the root causes of challenging behaviour is another critical step in effectively addressing the issues presented by difficult employees. Some common root causes include personal stress or life changes, lack of clear expectations or direction, inappropriate management styles, poor job fit, and insufficient training or resources. Understanding the underlying causes of an employee’s behaviour can help you implement targeted interventions that address the specific needs of the individual and promote a more successful workplace environment.

In conclusion, understanding difficult employees is an integral part of effective HR management. By identifying the types of difficult employees, recognising their impact on the workplace, and assessing the root causes of their behaviour, you can implement targeted interventions that promote a more prosperous and productive workplace environment.

difficult_employees playbook

Effective Communication Strategies

Clear communication is critical when dealing with difficult employees. Developing strong communication skills, such as active listening, empathy, constructive feedback, and setting clear expectations, can help address and resolve issues that arise with difficult employees.

Effective communication is a two-way street. It requires both the speaker and the listener to participate in the conversation actively. When dealing with difficult employees, it’s essential to approach the conversation with an open mind and a willingness to listen.

Active Listening and Empathy

Active listening involves giving full attention to the employee and genuinely being interested in their perspective. This allows you to create a safe space for open communication and allows the employee to share their concerns, frustrations, or suggestions. By displaying empathy, you demonstrate that you acknowledge their feelings and are dedicated to finding a solution.

It’s important to remember that active listening is not just about hearing what the employee is saying but also understanding their point of view. This involves asking questions and clarifying any misunderstandings to ensure that you fully comprehend their perspective.

Providing Constructive Feedback

Constructive feedback focuses on the employee’s behaviours and actions rather than attacking them personally. Feedback should be specific, objective, and timely. This encourages employees to take responsibility for their actions and look for ways to improve their performance.

When providing feedback, it’s important to be clear and concise. Avoid using vague language or generalisations, leading to misunderstandings and confusion. Instead, use specific examples to illustrate your points and provide actionable steps for improvement.

Setting Clear Expectations and Boundaries

Clearly outline your expectations and boundaries helps employees understand their roles and responsibilities within the company. Establishing and reinforcing consistent standards can improve performance and promote a positive work environment.

Setting clear expectations and boundaries also involves setting realistic goals and deadlines. This helps to ensure that employees understand what is expected of them and can work towards achieving those goals in a timely manner.

Overall, effective communication strategies are essential when dealing with difficult employees. By practising active listening, empathy, providing constructive feedback, and setting clear expectations, you can create a positive and productive work environment for everyone.

Conflict Resolution Techniques

Conflict is unavoidable in any workplace, but effectively managing conflict is essential to maintaining a healthy work environment. Employing conflict resolution techniques such as addressing issues early and privately, conducting mediation, and promoting collaboration can help resolve conflicts and prevent them from escalating.

Conflicts can arise from various sources, including differences in opinion, misunderstandings, and personality clashes. No matter the source, it’s important to address conflicts as soon as possible to prevent them from festering and causing further damage to the work environment.

Addressing Issues Early and Privately

When addressing conflicts, it’s essential to do so early and privately. This allows for a more open and honest conversation, free from the distractions and pressures of a public setting. By addressing issues early, you can prevent them from becoming larger problems requiring more time and resources.

When addressing conflicts privately, choosing a neutral location where both parties feel comfortable is essential. This could be a conference room or a private office. It’s also important to approach the conversation calmly and professionally, avoiding accusatory language or aggressive behaviour.

Mediation and Facilitating Dialogue

Mediation can be an effective tool for resolving conflicts between employees. An HR professional can serve as a neutral mediator, helping to facilitate constructive dialogue between the parties involved. Mediation encourages open communication, fostering better understanding and a potential resolution.

During mediation, the HR professional will listen to both parties and help them identify the underlying issues causing the conflict. They will then work with the parties to develop a plan to address the issues and move forward. This could include setting behaviour change goals, establishing a progress timeline, and following up to ensure the plan is working.

Encouraging Collaboration and Teamwork

Team-building activities and encouraging collaboration often help to resolve conflicts and create a more positive work environment. As an HR professional, consider organising events and activities promoting employee teamwork and cooperation. This can help rebuild trust and foster a sense of camaraderie in the workplace.

Team-building activities could include group projects, team-building exercises, or even social events outside of work. You can create a more positive and supportive work environment by encouraging employees to work together and get to know each other better.

In conclusion, managing conflict is essential to any HR professional’s job. Addressing issues early and privately, conducting mediation, and promoting collaboration can help resolve conflicts and create a more positive work environment for everyone.


Performance Management and Improvement

Performance management is a crucial aspect of any organisation, and it becomes even more critical when dealing with difficult employees. Difficult employees can be challenging to manage, but with the right approach, you can help them reach their full potential and contribute positively to the organisation.

One of the most effective ways to manage difficult employees is to set clear performance goals. When employees clearly understand what is expected of them, they are more likely to perform well. Measurable goals allow employees to track their progress and see how they contribute to the organisation’s success. Regular check-ins help identify any areas where the employee may be struggling and provide an opportunity for constructive feedback.

Setting Performance Goals and Monitoring Progress

Setting performance goals is just the first step. Monitoring progress is equally important. Regular check-ins can help you identify issues contributing to the employee’s problematic behaviour. It also allows one to recognise the employee’s achievements and provide positive feedback.

When monitoring progress, it’s essential to provide specific feedback. For example, instead of saying, “You need to improve your communication skills,” say, “I noticed that you interrupted your colleagues during the meeting. Let’s work on active listening skills to improve communication.”

Providing Training and Development Opportunities

Investing in employee development can help address skill gaps or performance weaknesses. Offering training programs, workshops, and mentoring opportunities can empower employees to improve their performance and help resolve any issues that may be contributing to their difficult behaviour.

Tailoring training and development opportunities to the employee’s specific needs is essential. For example, offer time management training or coaching if an employee struggles with time management. If an employee is struggling with communication, offer communication skills training.

See Also
HR Software

Implementing Performance Improvement Plans

If a difficult employee continues to underperform or exhibit problematic behaviour, consider implementing a performance improvement plan (PIP). A PIP outlines specific goals and expectations and a timeline for improvement. Regularly evaluate the employee’s progress and provide support as needed. If significant progress is not made by the end of the PIP timeline, further action may be necessary, including potential termination.

It’s essential to approach a PIP with a positive attitude. The goal is to help the employee improve, not to punish them. Be clear about the consequences of not meeting the PIP goals, but also offer support and resources to help the employee succeed.

In conclusion, managing difficult employees requires a proactive approach. Setting clear performance goals, monitoring progress, providing training and development opportunities, and implementing performance improvement plans can help these employees reach their full potential and contribute positively to the organisation.

The HR Playbook for Handling Difficult Employees

Legal and Ethical Considerations

When managing difficult employees, HR professionals must ensure that they adhere to employment laws and regulations, maintain proper documentation, and protect employee rights and privacy.

Understanding Employment Laws and Regulations

Being familiar with and adhering to relevant employment laws and regulations, such as anti-discrimination laws, labour laws, and privacy rights, is crucial. These laws are put in place to protect employees from unfair treatment and discrimination in the workplace. As an HR professional, you must ensure that your organisation complies with these laws and regulations.

For instance, anti-discrimination laws prohibit discrimination based on age, race, gender, religion, disability, and other protected characteristics. Ensuring that all employees are treated fairly and equally, regardless of their background or personal characteristics is vital.

On the other hand, labour laws govern the relationship between employers and employees, including issues such as minimum wage, overtime pay, and working conditions. It is crucial to ensure that your organisation complies with these laws to avoid legal and financial consequences.

Privacy rights are also an important consideration when managing difficult employees. Employees have a right to privacy regarding their personal information, such as medical records and financial information. As an HR professional, you must ensure that this information is kept confidential and secure.

Documenting Employee Issues and Actions

Maintain accurate and thorough documentation of all employee-related issues and actions to protect your organisation in case of disputes or legal claims. This includes performance evaluations, disciplinary actions, and any communications regarding employee issues. Documentation is essential to ensure a clear record of what has happened and what actions have been taken.

Documentation can also help to identify patterns of behaviour, which can be useful in addressing ongoing issues with difficult employees. For instance, if an employee has a history of being consistently late, documentation can help to demonstrate this pattern of behaviour and support any disciplinary action that may need to be taken.

Ensure that this documentation is stored securely in compliance with privacy regulations. This means that only authorised personnel should access this information, which should be stored securely.

Protecting Employee Rights and Privacy

As you address difficult employees, respecting their rights to privacy and confidentiality is essential. Avoid sharing sensitive information with others, and always be mindful of the employee’s dignity and reputation throughout the process.

It is also important to ensure that employees are aware of their rights and the resources available to them. This includes providing information about the organisation’s policies and procedures and any relevant laws and regulations. Employees should also be informed of their right to file a complaint or report any issues without fear of retaliation.

Finally, it is crucial to ensure that any disciplinary action taken is fair and consistent. This means that all employees should be held to the same standards, and disciplinary action should be based on objective criteria, such as performance or behaviour, rather than personal biases or preferences.

In conclusion, managing difficult employees is a complex and challenging aspect of human resources. By employing effective communication, conflict resolution techniques, performance management, and maintaining legal and ethical considerations, HR professionals can navigate these challenges and create a more harmonious and productive workplace environment.

Copyright 2023. The HR Guy | All Rights Reserved.